agent-pages

Clutch cutaway: re-check of PR #1 at 81cca6e

Download

Clutch cutaway: re-check of PR #1 at 81cca6e

PR: yachint/car-demos #1, Interactive clutch cutaway (cursor/clutch-cutaway-demo-ec31 → main) Re-checked at: 81cca6e (PR version 6). New since the first review:

First review: https://pages.yachint.in/p/clutch-cutaway-review-findings-and-accuracy-plan-ome5uevk (IDs R, P, T, M, A). Date: 2026-10-19

How this was checked:

New findings are numbered F1–F18. All file:line references point at 81cca6e.


1. Summary

Most of the first review landed. All 15 bugs from the code review are fixed or no longer apply, and every lesson behaves the same at every frame rate. The model now:

What's left:


2. Status of the first review

Item Status at 81cca6e
R1 engine at 0 rpm in the bite ✅ Fixed. A stall is now any rpm below 300. Holding the bite against the brake (1st, clutch 0.5, brake 0.5) idles at 593 rpm, which is physically consistent.
R2 starter disables stall detection ✅ Fixed. The starter only acts on a stopped engine; it's released on pointer up, cancel and leave and on window blur. A test covers it.
R3 touch point vs open/shift gate ✅ Fixed. CLUTCH_TOUCH, and open means no torque at all.
R4 lock clamp sign ✅ Fixed. Replaced by the grip-or-slip solve; a test checks there are no sign flips.
R5 arrow keys on a slider ✅ Fixed (main.js:133).
R6 plate gap from torque ⚠️ The gap now follows the pedal, but the parts don't touch. See F4.
R7 starter interlock ✅ Fixed. It needs the clutch down, even in neutral.
R8 soft-lock slip ✅ Fixed (removed).
R9 lug copy ✅ Split into brakes, gear, direction and lug. The "gear" case now rarely fires; see F1 and F11.
R10 first-gear special cases ✅ Fixed. 1st stalls on a release of 0.6 s or faster and creeps at 0.8 s or slower; reverse needs 1.0 s. Both are identical at 20–240 fps.
R11 frame hitch ✅ Fixed. Fixed 1/240 s steps, frames capped at 0.1 s, and inputs are no longer interpolated across a frame.
R12 pedal state on lesson start ✅ Fixed (the interpolation state is gone).
R13 held keys after blur ✅ Fixed.
R14 idle-creep check ✅ Fixed (sample().idleCreep).
R15 bite band ✅ Fixed (CSS variables set from the sim constants).
P1 grip-or-slip clutch ✅ Done.
P2 engine losses ✅ Done. Engine braking is 0.67 m/s² clutch up vs 0.21 clutch down.
P3 idle control and stall from torque balance ⚠️ Done, but the idle reserve is too strong at low rpm. See F1.
P4 calibration ✅ Done: 2,698 rpm at 100 km/h in 5th, 7.6 km/h idle creep, 92% drivetrain efficiency, about 4% extra equivalent mass.
T1 Pull away ⚠️ Peaks at 1,800 rpm with 3.9 kJ of slip, but the step text no longer matches. See F3.
T2 upshift without a blip ✅ Done. No flare; it ends at a 34.7 km/h cruise.
T3 brake in gear, clutch near idle ✅ Done, with a when step that sets the pedals.
T4 stall mechanism wording ✅ Done.
T5 labels ⚠️ Mostly done. The pedal reads "Up" when the pedal is halfway but the plates grip. See F12.
T6 narration in context ⚠️ Mostly done. Coasting in neutral with the clutch up is still wrong (F10), and the engine-braking text is wrong (F2).
T7 lever rules ⚠️ Done while the engine runs. With the engine off the checks are skipped (F8), and the neutral message is wrong (F9).
T8 starter copy ✅ Done.
T9 wording ✅ Done.
M1 clutch release direction ⚠️ Directions are now right: the bearing and finger tips move toward the engine, the plate lifts away, and the input shaft stays put. The parts still don't touch. See F4.
M2 pedals, lever, wheel, linkage ⚠️ Pedal order, H-pattern, lever and steering-wheel position are fixed, and the hydraulic linkage was added. But the pedals are now behind the steering wheel. See F6.
M3 gearbox motion ⚠️ Countershaft speed, free-spinning gears, sleeves, input-to-countershaft pair, 5th pair and tooth size are fixed. The reverse gears turn the wrong way. See F13.
M4 half-shafts and differential ⚠️ The spin sign is fixed and spider/side gears were added, but the ring and pinion no longer match FINAL. See F14.
M5 open wheels ✅ Done. Brake glow verified visible in Chrome.
M6 disc and flywheel details ✅ Done: 8 mm disc, 128-tooth ring gear, starter pinion meshes while cranking.
M7 proportions ✅ Done: 240 mm disc, crank lowered, pistons flush with the deck, crank on-axis.
A1–A6 audio ✅ All six done: cranking sound, tone from load, lugging judder, glide into the stall, grind, road layer. But see F7.

3. New findings

F1. Idle control is so strong that any gear keeps running from about 380 rpm (physics, high)

Gear Lowest speed that survives Engine at start Ends at
3rd 8 km/h 382 rpm 16.5 km/h
4th 11 km/h 378 rpm 19.6 km/h
5th 14 km/h 378 rpm 18.8 km/h

5th from 20 km/h starts at 541 rpm and speeds up to 27.3 km/h in 10 s with no throttle. Clutch torque is positive throughout (flow +0.51 → +0.19), so the engine is driving the car.

F2. The narration says "engine braking" while the engine is driving the car (narration, medium)

F3. The Pull away step text no longer matches the model (lessons, medium)

t Step on screen Pedal Engine / disc rpm km/h Mode
6.0 "A small rise in revs" ("brings the engine up to about 1,200–1,500 rpm") 0.63 722 / 58 0.5 slipping
7.0 " 0.62 848 / 493 4.4 slipping
8.0 "Hold the bite" ("The surfaces meet and slip") 0.41 1014 / 1014 9.0 locked
9.5 "Pedal up — the clamp shuts" ("The two rpm readings match") 0.10 1533 / 1533 13.7 locked since 8.0 s
11.0 "Idle alone is enough" 0.02 1800 / 1800 16.1 locked
at (s) Inputs What the model does Suggested title
2.0 clutch: 1 Pedal down, plates apart
4.0 gear: 1 First gear, while that gap is open
5.5 brake: 0, throttle: 0.1 (clutch still down) rises to about 1,150 rpm A small rise in revs ("about 1,100–1,200 rpm")
6.5 clutch: 0.62 slips 6.5–8.4 s; engine dips to about 700, disc climbs Find the bite
8.5 clutch: 0.3 already gripping at 767 rpm The plates grip ("the disc has caught up; the pedal can keep coming up")
9.6 clutch: 0.02 locked Pedal up — the clamp shuts
11.0 throttle: 0 settles at 833 rpm, 7.4 km/h Idle alone is enough

F4. The clutch parts still don't touch (3D, medium)

Pedal 0 (clamped) Pedal 0.82 (touch point) Pedal 1 (fully down)
Disc facing to flywheel 0 mm ✓ 0 mm 4 mm
Pressure plate to disc 11 mm 11 mm 16 mm
Bearing face to fingers (at bearing radius) about 20 mm about 11 mm about 10 mm
Finger tips (x) 0.702 0.730 0.735, past the disc hub (0.708–0.724) and into the flywheel face (0.725)

F5. The clutch inset is off-screen, nearly black, and blocked in Face view (UI / 3D, medium)

Seen in Chrome at a 1512×714 viewport.

F6. The pedals are now behind the steering wheel, and the Pedals camera doesn't show them (3D / cabin, medium)

F7. Turning Sound off doesn't silence the road noise (audio, low–medium)

F8. With the engine off, every gear-change check is skipped (gear rules, low–medium)

F9. Shifting to neutral is refused with grind and synchro text (gear rules / copy, low)

F10. Coasting in neutral with the clutch up says the wheels aren't turning (copy, low)

F11. Grammar in the generated copy (copy, low)

F12. The clutch readout says "Up" while the pedal is halfway (UI, low)

F13. The reverse gears turn the wrong way and overlap (3D, low)

F14. The ring and pinion no longer match FINAL (3D, low)

F15. The clutch labels pile up on each other (UI, low)

F16. The steering column and clutch line cross the Clutch camera (3D, low)

F17. Small consistency items (low)

F18. Keyboard users can't release the clutch slowly (input, low)


4. Suggested order

  1. F1 + F2 together (idle reserve, engine-braking and lugging text), plus a test that 5th at 20 km/h stalls.
  2. F3 with the tested timeline above.
  3. F4 + F5: make the clutch parts touch, and fix the inset's lighting, contents and placement.
  4. F6: footwell position and Pedals camera.
  5. F7–F12: audio mute, gear-change checks with the engine off, neutral copy, coasting copy, grammar, pedal readout.
  6. F13–F18: reverse gears, ring and pinion, labels, cable routing, consistency, keyboard clutch.

5. Tests to add